Loving Tan vs St Tropez Sunless Tanners

LuxeLuminous is reader supported. When you buy through our links, we may get a commission.

If you want that stunning J-Lo glow quickly, your best option is to use a self-tanner.

Self-tanners give you a stunning sun-kissed glow without having to spend hours in the sun or tanning beds exposing yourself to UV rays. Self-tanners are highly popular these days because of the ease of use and convenience they offer.

There are many self-tanners out there in different price ranges. However, if you have been researching even a little on the best self-tanners out there, then you must have come across two names: Loving Tan and St. Tropez.

These are two of the best and fastest-acting self-tanners out there. These are like bottles of liquid sunshine that give you an instant sun-kissed glow that you will absolutely love.

In this blog post, we are going to do a deep dive on Loving Tan vs St Tropez, and go over the advantages and disadvantages of both. So, if you are looking to buy a self-tanner among these two, keep reading! You will find some great information on both products here.


Why Loving Tan and St. Tropez?

St Tropez Tanning Mousse

There are countless self-tanners out there. A simple online search for self-tanners will yield hundreds of results. We’ve discussed a great number of brands here, including Tan Physics, Bondi Sands, Beauty By Earth, and Mystic Tan.

You can find all sorts of self-tanners including waters, foams, creams, mists, and lotions. All of these products claim to give you a stunning glow with their special sunshine serum.

Some of these products promise to give you a gradual sun-kissed glow with regular use while others give you the result in just a few hours.

There are also some bronzing self-tanners that give you instant results as soon as you apply them to your skin.

However, the success of a self-tanner depends on its formula. It should give you the perfect tan and glow without leaving your skin with any patches, streaks or an orange hue.

Out of all the different types of self-tanners available on the market, mousses tend to be the favorites of many. They are highly effective, quick, and easy to apply.

Both St. Tropez and Loving Tan offer self-tanning mousses and both the products have received great reviews from their customers.

Loving Tan and St. Tropez promise to give you a stunning, quick-dry, and streak-free tan with an appealing scent and hydrating qualities. Both Loving Tan and St. Tropez self-tanners have 4.5 stars out of 5 on Amazon which is solid.

Loving Tan vs. St. Tropez

Loving Tan

Now that you have had a basic introduction to these two brilliant self-tanners, let’s compare them and find out which is the best one.


Most self-tanners come with a distinct smell due to the active chemical DHA. While some people are alright with it, many of us hate the strong smells.

If you don’t want a typical chemical smell after you apply your self-tanner, then we suggest you go for St. Tropez. This is because there is a strong floral smell added to St. Tropez’s self-tanner which covers up the chemical smell.

However, it sometimes feels too overpowering and some also might find this flowery scent too strong to handle.

Loving Tan self-tanner, on the other hand, does not have any extra fragrance to cover up for the chemical smell. It has a mild chemical-like smell that isn’t too overpowering and one easily gets used to it.

If you don’t want to go too fancy with the smell, then we suggest you buy Loving Tan.


Loving Tan self-tanner comes in three color shades, dark, medium, and ultra-dark. You can pick one according to your preference and the end color payoff you want.

St. Tropez self-tanner, on the other hand, comes in just one color with three payoffs. It lets you choose the depth and darkness of your tan. If you want more brown color, you can increase your applications. St Tropez is a s tanning mousse.

Ease of Application and Blendability

When you pick a self-tanner, you must choose the one that is easy to apply and blend. The “blendability” of the self-tanner is very important.

You don’t want to be left with an uneven skin tone and streaks of tan on your skin. It will give your skin an uneven color that no one likes.

When it comes to Loving Tan and St. Tropez, the latter was easier to blend than the former. Loving Tan self-tanning mousse does give great coverage but it is much more difficult to blend as compared to St. Tropez. It is also difficult to get an even color on the skin with Loving Tan self-tanner because it takes some serious effort to blend into the skin.

St. Tropez self-tanner, on the other hand, blends into the skin easily. It gives an even color to the skin without any serious effort and the result is flawless sun-kissed skin. So, if you are someone who likes to put in the minimum effort for great results, then St. Tropez self-tanner is the best choice. With Loving Tan, you will need to do a little more hard work.

St. Tropez self-tanning mousse is also foamier and gives a medium brown color which makes its application easy and super smooth. Loving Tan, on the other hand, gives off a dark brown color with its application which makes it difficult to blend in.

See also:

Color Payoff

The color payoff of both products is amazing and quite similar. Therefore, it is difficult to pick one of the two. Both Loving Tan and St. Tropez give very similar end results when it comes to their color payoffs.

Loving Tan self-tanner gives a slightly darker color when applied to the skin.

You may need to rinse it off in the shower once or twice to get a natural sun-kissed color. So, if you are looking for a darker or olive end tan, then Loving Tan will be a good choice.

St. Tropez, on the other hand, gives a more natural and light camel brown color to the skin on its first application. Hence, if you like to keep things natural and not too dramatic, then St. Tropez is the right choice for you.

However, the end result of both the self-tanners is excellent. It just depends on whether you want a lighter skin tone or a darker one. Some people love to go a little darker and that’s why they pick Loving Tan. For others, a camel-colored tan is enough so they prefer St. Tropez.

Lasting Time

When it comes to the time the two self-tanners last, there was a tie between both the products. Both the self-tanners have great lasting power and last for a good 5-6 days without any reapplication.

They also looked fairly similar a few days after their application even in different types of lighting. Thus, they last for almost the same amount of time.


The ingredients of a beauty product are a very important consideration when you are choosing any beauty or skincare product. Products that are full of chemicals put you at high risk for allergies and skin issues. Therefore, it is important to do a small patch test before you apply any skincare or beauty product on your skin.

Hence, before you go on and immerse yourself in the self-tanning experience of either St. Tropez or Loving Tan, we suggest you do a patch test. This will tell you if you are allergic to any of the ingredients present in the two self-tanning mousses.

Both loving Tan and St. Tropez claim their products to use 100% natural DHA. They are also alcohol and paraben-free.

St. Tropez is also free of phthalates and sulfates, which makes it potentially safer as compared to Loving Tan mousse.

Ingredients of Loving Tan

The ingredients of Loving Tan self-tanning mousse include the following:

Dihydroxyacetone, Deionized Water, Propylene Glycol, Witch Hazel, Ethoxydiglycol, Decyl Glucoside, D Panthenol, Erythrulose, Phenoxyethanol Ethyl Hexyl Glycerin, Julans Nigra, Fragrance, Aloe Vera, Sodium Bisulfite, Hydroxypropyl Methylcellulose, Red 33 (CI 14700), FD & C Red 40 (CI 16035), Yellow 5 (CI 19140), FD & C Blue 1 (CI 42090), Caramel.

It also contains organic DHA and is free of alcohol and parabens.

Ingredients of St. Tropez

Water, Caramel, Dihydroxyacetone, Propylene Glycol, Glycerin, Ethoxydiglycol, PPG-5-Ceteth-20, Phenoxyethanol, Decyl Glucoside, Hydroxyethylcellulose, Melanin, Fragrance, Alpha-isomethyl Ionone, Sodium Metabisulfite, Dimethyl Isosorbide, Linalool, Ethylhexylglycerin, Potassium Sorbate, Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Juice, CI 42090 (Blue 1), CI 19140 (Yellow 5), CI 14700 (Red 4), Citric Acid.

St. Tropez is also free of phthalates, sulfates, and parabens. It also contains 100% natural DHA.

While the ingredients used in both Loving Tan and St. Tropez self-tanner are generally safe, St. Tropez is also free from sulfates which makes it an even safer option than Loving Tan.

That being said, none of the users of any of these self-tanners have faced any allergic reactions or skin issues after using these products. However, to be on the safe side, we suggest you conduct a patch test before applying the self-tanning mousse all over your skin.

Pros and Cons of St. Tropez


  • Gives a natural tan
  • Easy to work with
  • Leaves no streaks or uneven color


  • Strong smell
  • Doesn’t work well with darker skin tones
  • Best results appear when used with guide color on
St.Tropez Self Tan Classic Bronzer Mousse Foam, Original Fake Tan, Streak-Free Finish, Develops in 4-8 hours, Vegan, Natural & Cruelty Free, 8 fl oz
  • Our most iconic, fool proof and...
  • Long-lasting, lightweight and 100% clean...
  • Use our tan Applicator Mitt for trusted...
  • English (Publication Language)

Pros and Cons of Loving Tan


  • Mild and better smell
  • Comes with a bright guide color which prevents you from missing any spot
  • Works for darker skin tones and gives your skin a natural glow


  • Application is difficult because of the dark color
  • Dries up quickly which makes application difficult
  • Difficult to blend
Loving Tan 2 Hour Express Deluxe Bronzing Mousse - Medium
  • Made By Tan Lovers For Tan Lovers –...
  • Colour Guide Technology – The built-in...
  • Professional Strength & Dermatologist...
  • How To Use – 1. Apply moisturiser...

Loving Tan vs St. Tropez – Who’s the Winner?

While it is difficult to pick one of these two amazing self-tanners, most tanning obsessives are inclined towards St. Tropez self-tanners.

While it doesn’t mean that Loving Tan self-tanner doesn’t have a customer base because it is a cult favorite for many people, what makes St. Tropez better of the two is that it offers versatility when it comes to the color payoff.

So, if you are new to self-tanning regimes, then you will find it easy to work with St. Tropez self-tanner.

Written by Kayla Young

Kayla is the founder of LuxeLuminous. She has worked professionally in the tanning industry for years. She has been interested in esthetics since childhood, and has tried every hair, skin, and makeup product ever produced (more or less).