in ,

Best Tanning Lotion Without Bronzer

LuxeLuminous is reader supported. When you buy through our links, we may get a commission.

Sometimes you put on tanning lotion, but you end up getting your clothes and fabrics darker than your skin! Even if you wait for it to dry, lotion can still rub onto your clothes and cause unsightly stains.

The main culprits here are the bronzers. These agents instantly add color to the skin, but that color can also transfer to your clothes and other fabrics — particularly light colors. For more information on bronzers, see our Buyer’s Tips section below.

The solution is to choose tanning lotions without bronzers. After a thorough look at these products, we’ve found that the best tanning lotion without bronzer is the Beauty By Earth Tanning Lotion.


Our Top Pick: Beauty by Earth Tanning Lotion

Beauty by Earth Tanning Lotion

Key Points at a Glance

  • Made of Natural Ingredients
  • Safe for all skin types
  • Moisturizing
  • Sunless Tanning
  • No Parabens and No Phthalates
  • Volume: 7.5 oz
  • Consistency: Thick Lotion

The Beauty by Earth tanning lotion is by far the best tanning lotion without bronzer that we can find. It’s a self-tanner so that means you don’t need to go to a tanning bed or under the sun to achieve glowing tanned skin.

Beauty by Earth is most proud of the ingredients of their tanning lotion. It is mostly made with natural and organic ingredients like aloe vera juice, shea butter, coconut oil, green tea leaf extract, and many more. With natural ingredients, you don’t have to risk your health just to make yourself more beautiful and confident by tanning.

Beauty by Earth Tanning Lotion Side by Side

The color produced is buildable so you can reapply the product when you want a deeper tan. Just make sure you don’t shave then immediately use it or else you’ll develop dark spots. Most users were very happy with the tan they had with it but there are still some who complained about being orange.

Many users also note that this lotion has a thick formulation. For some, it can be difficult to blend but others were able to evenly spread it on their body. Many agree that a little goes a long way.

Beauty by Earth Tanning Lotion Side by Side

Most users say that they didn’t have any problem with it staining their clothes or sheets. There are also mixed views about the scent. Some said that it smelled like coconuts, others say it doesn’t smell like anything and then there are others who were greatly disappointed with the scent.

Self Tanner - With Organic Aloe Vera & Shea Butter, Sunless Tanning Lotion and Bronzer Buildable Light, Medium or Dark Tan for Natural Looking Fake Tan, Self Tanners Best Sellers (7.5oz)
  • Say hello to perfect sun-kissed skin: Our self...
  • Get your tan without sun damage: No sun needed...
  • Your skin will thank you: Perfect alternative to...
  • Wont turn your skin orange: If you have sensitive...
  • Love it or let us know: We know you're gonna love...

Best Tanning Lotion Without Bronzer: Comparison Table

Preview
Top Choice!
Self Tanner - With Organic Aloe Vera & Shea Butter, Sunless Tanning Lotion and Bronzer Buildable Light, Medium or Dark Tan for Natural Looking Fake Tan, Self Tanners Best Sellers (7.5oz)
Runner-Up
Devoted Creations #TANLIFE Hydrating Tanning Butter - 12.25 oz.
Budget Pick
Pro Tan Hot Tottie Hot Action Tanning Lotion 8.5oz
Best for Gradual Tan
Norvell Prolong Sunless Tanning Color Extender Moisturizing Lotion, 8.5 fl.oz.
Best for Sensitive Skin
Hempz Dark Tan Maximizer, Hypoallergenic, 9 Ounce
Name
Beauty by Earth
Devoted Creations
Pro Tan
Norvell
Hempz
Price on Amazon
$30.99
$18.10
$9.38
Price not available
$17.77
Top Choice!
Preview
Self Tanner - With Organic Aloe Vera & Shea Butter, Sunless Tanning Lotion and Bronzer Buildable Light, Medium or Dark Tan for Natural Looking Fake Tan, Self Tanners Best Sellers (7.5oz)
Name
Beauty by Earth
Price on Amazon
$30.99
Buy on Amazon
Runner-Up
Preview
Devoted Creations #TANLIFE Hydrating Tanning Butter - 12.25 oz.
Name
Devoted Creations
Price on Amazon
$18.10
Buy on Amazon
Budget Pick
Preview
Pro Tan Hot Tottie Hot Action Tanning Lotion 8.5oz
Name
Pro Tan
Price on Amazon
$9.38
Buy on Amazon
Best for Gradual Tan
Preview
Norvell Prolong Sunless Tanning Color Extender Moisturizing Lotion, 8.5 fl.oz.
Name
Norvell
Price on Amazon
Price not available
Buy on Amazon
Best for Sensitive Skin
Preview
Hempz Dark Tan Maximizer, Hypoallergenic, 9 Ounce
Name
Hempz
Price on Amazon
$17.77
Buy on Amazon

Our Runner Up: Devoted Creations Tanning Butter

Devoted Creations Tanning Butter

Key Points at a Glance

  • Suitable for Sensitive Skin
  • Ultra-moisturizing
  • Anti-aging and Skin-firming
  • Protects tattoos from fading
  • Volume 12.25 fl. oz
  • Consistency: Thick Lotion

The Devoted Creations #Tanlife Tanning Butter comes close to the top but remains as the first runner up. To achieve a tan with this product, you still need to go under a tanning bed.

What’s great about this is the shea butter content. This is an excellent moisturizer and a lot of users stand by the statement that it really moisturizes even the dryest skin to make it soft and smooth. Additionally, it also contains substances that help protect your tattoos from fading.

Also included in the formula is matrixyl synthe 6, which helps prevent premature aging of the skin. Along with aqualcell, it helps reduce fine lines and wrinkles all over the body.

This lotion comes in a thick formula, due to the shea butter present. It softly melts into the skin until it becomes spreadable all over the body. Many customers also love that the formula isn’t greasy or sticky at all but is very moisturizing to the skin.

For the scent, most customers say it has a clean citrus scent. After tanning with it on a sunbed, some customers were still able to smell a faint bad odor characteristic of tanning lotions used on a sunbed. Some prefer it over other brands because the smell is not that strong.

Devoted Creations #TANLIFE Hydrating Tanning Butter - 12.25 oz.
  • 1.Super soft tanning butter build and maintain...
  • 2.Sensitive Skin Shea Butter Formula.
  • 3.Provides anti-aging and skin firming benefits...
  • 4.AcquaCell for fine line and wrinkle reducing...
  • 5.Tattoo & Color Fade Protectors

Best Budget: Pro Tan Hot Tottie Lotion

Pro Tan Hot Tottie Lotion

Key Points at a Glance

  • Contains Vitamin A, C, and E
  • Moisturizing Effect
  • Heat And Tingle For Glow
  • Volume: 8.5 fl. Oz
  • Consistency: Creamy Lotion

Your budget will thank you if you get this Hot Tottie Lotion. This is the most affordable out of all the tanning lotions without bronzers that we reviewed. This helps accelerate the production of melanin when the skin is exposed to UV light.

This is a tingle lotion and that may take some getting used to. For some users, this lotion stings but others are used to the tingle and they say that it is a mild one. Some also add that this is a great beginner tingle lotion. On the contrary, there are also some users who say that it has a very slight tingle that some can’t even feel.

This product causes temporary redness when applied because it increases the blood circulation in that area. The redness will typically go away in about 30 minutes. Many customers find that after the redness, the tan produced is even and not streaky.

Many users also love how smooth the product is and how easy it is to spread. Additionally, most customers are satisfied with the scent. It is not that great but it isn’t that bad either.

Although it is a very affordable product, those who have sensitive skin may not be compatible with this product. Those who haven’t used tingle lotions may also be surprised with the “tingle”. Some describe it as being a hot, burning, or tingling sensation.


Best for Gradual Tanning: Norvell Prolong Tanning Lotion

Norvell Prolong Tanning Lotion

Key Points at a Glance

  • Buildable Tan
  • Restores Dehydrated Skin
  • Hydrates WithTime-Release Microcapsules
  • Odor Encapsulation Technology
  • Cruelty-Free
  • Volume: 8.5 fl oz
  • Consistency: Thin Lotion

It’s not easy to find a product that can give you a tan that you can customize to your liking but Norvell does with their Prolong Tanning Lotion. Apply the lotion once for a natural tan and apply again the next day to deepen the tan. It allows you to choose how dark you want your skin to be.

Norvell Prolong Tanning Lotion Benefits

Effective as a self-tanner, this product is also great as a moisturizer. It uses time-release microcapsules to make sure the skin is hydrated up to 24 hours. At that time, it helps restore dehydrated skin, conceals imperfections and builds a natural tan.

It comes in a thin lotion consistency which is easy to spread and is easily absorbed by the skin. Some people also prefer to use this as a tan extender. After a spray tan or after tanning on a sunbed this can be used to cover up any missed spots or to even out the complexion.

Like other self-tanners, this also has the same odor but much fainter. That’s because of the odor encapsulation molecules that help keep the odor trapped.

Norvell Prolong Sunless Tanning Color Extender Moisturizing Lotion, 8.5 fl.oz.
  • CREATE & MAINTAIN THE PERFECT TAN: Norvell’s #1...
  • HEALS, CORRECTS, AND PROTECTS: This Norvell tan...
  • SAFE AND CRUELTY FREE: Norvell’s proprietary tan...
  • APPLICATION TIPS: To avoid coloring of palms use...

Best for Sensitive Skin: Hempz Tanning Lotion

Hempz Tanning Lotion

Key Points at a Glance

  • 100% Natural Pure Hemp Seed Oil
  • Hydrates Skin
  • Includes Calming Extracts
  • Lightweight Formula
  • Odorless
  • Volume: 9 fl. oz

Many products can claim that they are hypoallergenic and can be used even for sensitive skin but only a few hold on to that promise. Hempz Tanning Lotion performs as promised. It is great for sensitive skin because of the natural ingredients in it. Plus, it’s also unscented so it doesn’t have any of the chemical fragrance that can be brutal on sensitive skin.

The hemp seed oil, which is 100% pure and natural, helps in making sure that the skin is adequately moisturized to make sure your tan lasts. Additional mango seed butter is also used for even more hydration so that the skin can look radiant and glowing.

To soothe and calm the skin, an oatmeal extract is also included in the formula. This product is meant to be used before going under a sunbed. It can also be used under the sun but make sure to use sunscreen to protect the skin.

Many customers love the product because it doesn’t irritate even those with very sensitive skin. Some find that this is really just a good moisturizer for the skin but it doesn’t really help deepen the tan you ought to get when using a tanning bed or basking under the sun.

Sale
Hempz Dark Tan Maximizer, Hypoallergenic, 9 Ounce
  • 1.Natural calming extracts including Oatmeal to...
  • 2.Blended with rich Mango Seed Butter to help...
  • 3.Non-greasy, lighweight formula absorbs quickly...
  • 4.Paraben Free, Gluten Free, Nut Free, 100% Vegan,...

Tanning Lotion Without Bronzer Buyer’s Guide

best tanning lotion without bronzer

Bronzers are great if you want to see that immediate color. Some even use it as a guide so that they’ll know where they’ve already applied the tanning lotion.

Useful as it may seem, it can still be annoying to get your clothes stained with bronzers. You just can’t rock a white or lightly colored outfit when you just got your skin tanned with a tanning lotion with bronzer. If you don’t need instant tanning right at that minute, skipping the bronzer can be a great idea.

Picking the right lotion can be tricky, though. This is because the bronzers in tanning lotions are defined differently by brands. Some brands claim DHA (Dihydroxyacetone) as a bronzer. Other brands consider bronzers those chemicals that instantly color the skin.

Some call products with DHA as “self-tanners”. The laws and regulations created by the FDA don’t define either of the terms so they are loosely used in the tanning industry.

Confused yet? Don’t worry, we’re here to help.

To clarify things, we define bronzers in this article as those chemicals that impart an instant color on the skin. These can be washed away easily and are also known as cosmetic bronzers.

Note: Tanning lotions without cosmetic tanners but with DHA can still stain your clothing. The reaction between DHA happens on the epithelial cells but the epithelial cells can still shed off and rub on your clothes.

Although this can also stain, the color is only minimal compared to products with cosmetic bronzers.

Who Should Buy a Tanning Lotion Without Bronzer

Tanning lotions without bronzers are useful for many people. The main function of tanning lotions is to provide enough moisture to the body to make it suitable for tanning evenly. Therefore, this product is ideal for those who want to get a tan, either through the chemical reaction of DHA or through the UV rays of a tanning bed or the sun.

They are ideal for those who want to tan by using self-tanning lotions without excessively staining their clothes. Although self- tanners may still rub off on the clothes, the stain is minimal and is not as excessive as those with bronzers. It is also great for those who don’t mind not having a tan instantly upon application.

Some people may use the bronzer as a guide to tanning because it changes the color of the skin it is applied to. This may not be needed by people who already have lots of experience in spreading a tanning lotion all over their bodies. In this case, the tanning lotion without bronzer is a great choice.

Tanning lotions without bronzers can also be used by those who are going to have a session at a tanning bed. These less likely to color the tanning bed, which can also be difficult to remove. Similarly, some tanning salon owners would also prefer their clients to use tanning lotions without bronzers to better protect their machines.

Important Features to Consider

Before you focus on the features of a tanning lotion without bronzer, you should know that they come in many forms. There are self-tanners, accelerators, maximizers, and tingle lotions, just to name a few. Each would be formulated differently because they also function differently. Some may have features that others don’t have because they are of different forms.

Note: Some tanning lotions can produce a tan without UV exposure while others won’t work unless you tan under a tanning bed or under the sun.

In that light, we’ve come up with a list of features that is suitable across all forms. Such features include the following:

List Of Ingredients

One of the first things to look at when buying products is the ingredients list. Sure it’s hard to read some of them but reading them gives us an idea about what they are made up of. Those who are looking for natural products can see if most of those listed are names of plants rather than names of chemicals.

Aside from checking the ingredient list, some products intentionally boast some of the ingredients that they use to gather more interest. Make sure that these ingredients are really high-quality and are really what they claim to be.

Compatibility With All Skin Types

Tanning lotions cause reactions to the skin, whether it is only on the outer skin layer or the deeper layers where melanin is produced. Some people have sensitive skin that may react negatively to the lotion. If an incompatible lotion is used, it can cause redness, rashes, or inflammation.

In response to sensitive skin, some companies develop formulations that are more gentle. Careful selection of ingredients are used to make sure even those with sensitive skin can tolerate them

Similarly, there are also products that offer extra moisturization. These are best for those who have very dry skin. It helps hydrate the skin to make it suitable for tanning.

Moisturizing Power

The main function of tanning lotions without bronzers is to moisturize the skin. It prepares the skin for the tanning session that would happen. Some tanning lotions are better at moisturization because they are designed that way.

The moisturization power of the products will depend on the ingredients used and the percentage of moisturizer to the rest of the ingredients. Nevertheless, it is best to find a tanning lotion that is moisturizing rather than drying.

Drying products will produce dry patches and these don’t tan as well as moisturized skin. Eventually, you’ll end up with an even tan if the skin is not properly moisturized.

Scent

Scent can be a minor issue for some but it can also be a major issue for others. It is best to find unscented products especially if you’re buying them online. In this way, you won’t have to use a product you dread just because of the scent. Additionally, people with sensitive skin can also be sensitive to fragrance.

If your skin isn’t sensitive to fragrance, then you should at least choose a scent that you love. You’d be lathering the lotion all over your body so choose a scent that relaxes you.

Also, take note that the scent the lotion may come in is not permanent. Some change in odor as time passes by or when UV rays have already caused a reaction to the body.

Additional Benefits

Apart from moisturizing benefits, there are also other benefits that tanning lotions feature. This includes anti-aging benefits, skin-firming benefits and the presence of tattoo fade protectors. Depending on your skin, you may or may not need these additional benefits.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you apply sunscreen over tanning lotions without bronzers?

Yes, you can apply sunscreen over tanning lotions without bronzers. Just make sure that the product is already completely dry or else you can dilute the product and cause streaking. Also, remember that although you’re protecting your skin from UV rays, tanning beds may not work as efficiently as using it without adding sunscreen.

Are tanning lotions without bronzers okay to use on the face?

Some tanning lotions without bronzers have a gentle formula that can be used even for sensitive skin. This makes some people confident enough to use it on their face. If you have sensitive skin or are unsure on how your face will react, it is best not to use these products for the face.

The skin on the face is more fragile. It is thinner than the other parts of the body, especially near the eye area. Plus, if you use other skincare products for the face, the tan you get out of the tanning lotions will probably fade much faster than the body, especially if you’re using micro-exfoliating or peeling products.

Can you prevent this from staining clothes and sheets?

Due to the absence of bronzers, these tanning lotions won’t stain as much. Nevertheless, there is still a chance for this to stain your clothes and sheets. To lessen that chance, make sure you let it dry up completely first before putting your clothes on.


Other Products We Looked At:

Australian Gold Tanning Lotion

Australian Gold Tanning Lotion

Key Points at a Glance

  • Cocoa Dreams Fragrance
  • Contains Vitamin A and E
  • Non-greasy Formula

The tanning lotion by Australian Gold maximizes your tan with it’s non-bronzer and non-tingle lotion. It helps achieve a beautiful tan without turning the skin orange. The formula includes a blend of natural oils that stimulates the production of melanin upon UV exposure.

While it deepens the tan, it also helps protect the skin cells from UV damage with Vitamin A and E content. This product is suitable for indoor tanning or outdoor tanning but it doesn’t contain any SPF so sunscreen is still needed for outdoor use.

Although there are many customers that agree about its effectiveness in stimulating the production of melanin, there are still some who are not fans of the product. Many describe the smell as similar to an orange creamsicle. Some love it while others hated it.

Australian Gold Dark Tanning Accelerator Lotion, 8.5 Fluid Ounce
Vitamins A and E: Work to deeply moisturize and provide superior benefits to skin
$23.95

Mystic Tan Gradual Tanning Lotion

Mystic Tan Gradual Tanning Lotion

Key Points at a Glance

  • Hypoallergenic
  • Odorless
  • Customizable Tan

Mystic Tan produces a few notable tanning-related products and their Gradual Tanning Lotion is one of them. This lotion tans the skin without needing UV exposure. Moreover, deepening the tan is possible by reapplying the product.

Aside from tanning the skin, it also helps the skin by nourishing, hydrating, soothing and protecting the skin cell with its blend of botanicals including green tea extract, avocado oil, aloe vera, and walnut shell extract.
Mystic Tan also claims that their products do not produce the orange undertone. Some customers testify that it is true but there are still some users who say their skin turned orange.

This lotion also uses the D-Odor 200 that helps prevent the usual self-tanner odor. Some were only able to smell a faint scent while there are still others who thought the scent was too strong.


Tanceuticals Tanning Lotion

Tanceuticals Tanning Lotion

Key Points at a Glance

  • Healthy for the Skin
  • Fast-Drying
  • Moneyback Guarantee

Tanceuticals Tanning Lotion is a recipient of various awards from beauty editors as a non-streak self-tanner. It features a blend of ingredients such as mango butter, vitamin E and acai berry, which are all good for the skin.

This product has a thin consistency and that makes it easy to apply and dry. With the absence of a bronzer, some found it difficult to identify where it was already applied to. This also means that it doesn’t transfer much to clothing especially if you dry it off first.

Most customers enjoyed the sweet scent but they say that it doesn’t last long because the fake tanner scent starts to develop after about an hour after application.

Although it seems to be a great product, you only get about 4.2 oz per bottle. Some customers say that they can only get about 3 body applications even if they aren’t that big.


Botanic Tree Tanning Lotion

Botanic Tree Tanning Lotion

Key Points at a Glance

  • For Body and Face
  • Natural & Organic Extracts
  • Sunless Tanning

This tanning lotion by Botanic Tree can be used for both the face and body. It is made from a combination of shea butter and natural ingredients like avocado, apricot, jojoba, rosemary, vanilla, linseed, grape seed, coconut, moringa, and passion fruit.

The unique combination creates a moisturizing product that also tans the body. It can be applied to the body repeatedly to deepen the tan. Most customers were able to get an even and deep tan color upon repeated application.

Due to its thick consistency, some find it difficult to spread the product evenly. Some even complained about patches or blotches. Some also said that the tanner works well but it still had a little orange hue.
Another complaint is the strong smell after the product has been applied to the skin. Although the strong scent doesn’t immediately appear, customers start to notice it as hours go by.


Ed Hardy Coconut Kisses Tanning Lotion

Ed Hardy Coconut Kisses Tanning Lotion

Key Points at a Glance

  • Possibly a Counterfeit listing
  • Boosts Tanning
  • Wonderful Scent

The Ed Hardy brand is quite popular when it comes to tanning lotions. And while we love Ed, we’re not entirely sure this listing is actually an Ed Hardy listing. It appears that this may be a fake listing, or a knockoff. Regardless, this should give you pause.

Assuming this listing isn’t fake, there are a few variations of this lotion available. This one doesn’t use any bronzing agents. It boosts melanin formation by using tyrosine blend, MelanoBronze, and Melactiva in its formulation.

Apart from boosting melanin, it also uses coconut oil and coconut milk to hydrate the skin. These also help with the wonderful scent that makes you feel like your on a tropical paradise. It has a thicker consistency but it is still spreadable.

There are many customers who have already purchased this product and most of them rate it highly. They loved the product for its nice scent, moisturizing effect, and melanin-boosting capabilities. Many agree that it has helped them achieve a deeper tan without looking orange. Still, some didn’t see any boosting effect and just considered it as a fragrant and good moisturizer.

And as we said, authenticity is a big question mark here.


Conclusion

Of all the tanning lotions with bronzers that have been reviewed, the Beauty by Earth Tanning Lotion is the best of them all. It tans the skin without the need to go under a tanning bed. Plus, it is made of a combination of natural ingredients that’s safe for the skin. The tan is also easily buildable.

Coming in second is the Devoted Creations Tanning Butter. This also effectively moisturizes the skin plus provides anti-aging functions. Those with tattoos will also love this because it protects them from fading.

If your budget is tight, there is also the Pro Tan Hot Tottie Lotion, which is a tingle lotion. It can help achieve a better-looking tan but the tingle it produces can be uncomfortable to those who haven’t tried tingle lotions before.


Smiling Redhead

Best Tanning Lotion for Fair Skin: Go for the Gold!

Best Spray Tan Tent! 10 Top Pop-Up Tanning Booths.